Quick answer
Choose the Staub 11-inch traditional deep skillet if you want one versatile pan for searing, saucing, and everyday cooking. Choose the Staub 10-inch Pure Grill if you regularly want visible grill marks and a round, double-handle pan for indoor grilling.
Shape and surface: the real difference
Both pans are cast iron, so they share heat retention and oven-to-table durability. The practical split is the cooking surface: the fry pan has a smooth interior, while the Pure Grill has a ridged surface. A smooth surface gives full contact for browning and lets you build a pan sauce without the ridges trapping liquid. A ridged surface lifts food slightly, creating grill marks and letting fat drain away, but it also means less contact area and more cleanup in the grooves.
Where each pan earns its keep
The deep skillet's taller sides make it more than a flat fry pan: you can stir, toss, and simmer without splashing, which suits one-pan meals, shallow frying, and reducing sauces after searing. The Pure Grill's round double-handle design is built for lifting and turning, and its ridged bed is best for foods you want marked and drained—think burgers, vegetables, or thick chops. For steak specifically, a smooth skillet typically gives more even crust because the whole surface contacts the meat; a grill pan gives attractive marks but can leave pale gaps between ridges.
Size and handling trade-offs
The fry pan is listed at 11 inches and the Pure Grill at 10 inches, so the skillet offers slightly more cooking area for searing multiple pieces or building a whole meal. The grill's double handles help with a heavy cast-iron pan, but its round shape and ridges make it less efficient for saucy dishes. Neither pan is nonstick; cast iron needs seasoning and careful cleaning, and the grill's ridges demand a brush to reach the grooves. If you want one pan that does most jobs, the skillet is the lower-friction choice.
Key trade-offs to weigh
- Smooth vs ridged surface: A smooth skillet gives more contact for browning and easier pan sauces; a ridged grill gives marks and drainage but less contact and more crevices to clean. If even browning matters more than grill marks, pick the skillet.
- Deep sides vs round grill: The deep skillet contains splatter and supports one-pan cooking; the round Pure Grill is better for turning and lifting marked foods but less suited to saucy dishes.
- Size and storage: The 11-inch skillet offers more surface area than the 10-inch grill, but both are heavy cast iron—measure your burner and storage space before deciding. Check your largest burner and cabinet height before ordering.
Product facts
- Buy Staub Cast Iron - Fry Pans/ Skillets Frying pan traditional: Staub Cast Iron 11-inch Traditional Deep Skillet in Pistachio The deep sides and smooth surface make it a strong single-pan choice for searing, simmering, and pan sauces.

Buy Staub Cast Iron - Fry Pans/ Skillets Frying pan traditional - Buy Staub Cast Iron Pure grill: Staub Cast Iron 10-inch Round Double Handle Pure Grill in Grenadine The ridged round grill is built for marking and draining, with two handles to help manage its cast-iron weight.

Buy Staub Cast Iron Pure grill
Which pan fits you?
Best for
- Cooks who want one versatile cast-iron pan for searing, saucing, and one-pan meals
- Buyers who prioritize even browning and easy cleanup over grill marks
Not for
- Cooks who mainly want visible grill marks and fat drainage
- Anyone who prefers a lighter pan or a nonstick surface


